Paid traffic is rented. Here's how email helps you own it
The number
When a sign-up form asks for a phone number straight after an email address, 25% to 45% of people close it before they reach the offer.
Guest article by Gavin Hewitson, founder of In-box.
Every click from Google Ads costs money, and most of those visitors will leave without booking or enquiring. In that case, the click is gone, and you paid for an introduction without any follow-up.
The problem with paid ads is that once someone leaves your site, there's often no way to reach them again without paying for another click. Getting an email address will help you follow up after the first visit and convert them into a buyer.
Why most paid clicks don't convert the first time
People researching services rarely make a decision in one sitting. They compare options, check reviews, ask a partner, get distracted, and often put their research on hold.
A landing page might work well for people ready to enquire, but what about everyone who's still comparing options? Landing pages do very little for the much larger group that is interested but not necessarily ready to choose.
Give people a reason to leave their email address
If someone has just searched for a service, think about what information would help them make a decision. A buyer's guide, quote estimator, or checklist might be enough to get their email address.
At In-box, we've built sign-up forms for more than 500 brands, and the clearest lesson we've learned is to ask for one thing at a time. When a form asks for a phone number right after asking for an email address, 25% to 45% of people close the form before they even reach the offer.
Prioritise getting an email address first and ask for more later. Our three sign-up form tweaks that boost conversion fast cover the rest.
Follow up with a simple sequence
Once someone is on your email list, the automated sequence does most of the heavy lifting:
- Email 1 (immediately): Deliver what you promised and introduce yourself.
- Email 2 (day 2 or 3): Answer the most common question or objection.
- Email 3 (day 5 or 6): Show proof such as a result, a review, or a short case study.
- Email 4 (day 8 or 9): Offer a clear, low-pressure next step.
Make your first email plain text. It reads like a note from a real person, which is exactly the kind of personalisation that makes a service business stand out. It's also more likely to land in the inbox instead of the spam folder. Here's how to use plain-text emails for higher opens.
Measure what it adds to your ad spend
Some people who ignored your original offer may book after receiving two or three useful emails. Track those conversions to see how much additional business your email follow-ups generate and how it affects your effective cost per acquisition.
If you're interested in starter templates, our free Figma email template pack includes welcome sequence designs.
About the author
Gavin Hewitson is the founder of In-box, a Klaviyo Master Gold Partner agency. Over five years, he and his team have worked with more than 500 brands on email and SMS. See their results at in-box.com/case-studies, or download their free Figma email template pack.

