← All lettersEmail Marketing

    Getting found in AI search is only half the job

    Gavin Hewitson
    Founder of In-box, guest writer26 October 2026
    3 min read

    The number

    Engaged subscribers can receive around 15 emails a month without hurting inbox placement. The full list should get closer to three.

    Guest article by Gavin Hewitson, founder of In-box.

    People are already using ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity to compare businesses. Naturally, businesses want to appear in those recommendations. But appearing in an AI answer doesn't guarantee someone will contact you, let alone become a customer.

    What happens after someone finds your business?

    Someone who discovers your business through ChatGPT still needs to decide whether they trust you enough to enquire. They might check your reviews, compare prices, or visit your website a few times before they decide to get in touch.

    If someone has already narrowed their choices down to a few businesses, a useful follow-up email could be what brings them back to yours.

    What to do when a new visitor arrives

    • Make the next step obvious: Book a call, request a quote, or join a list.
    • Offer something for those not ready: A short guide or checklist builds credibility and gives hesitant visitors a reason to stay connected.
    • Follow up quickly and personally: A plain-text personal welcome email within minutes beats a polished one sent days later.
    • Send more frequently to engaged subscribers: Send regular emails to the people who actually open them. In our accounts, people who regularly open your emails can receive around 15 a month without hurting your inbox placement. Your full list, including people who rarely open, should get closer to three per month.

    Make sure your emails actually arrive

    None of this works if your follow-up lands in the "Promotions" tab, or worse, the spam folder. Set up a branded sending domain, send to your engaged contacts first, and keep a close eye on bounces. We cover the full details in why your emails land in Promotions and how to fix it.

    Why this matters as discovery gets less predictable

    Search engine rankings and AI answers change constantly. Once someone subscribes to your emails, you have a way to contact them directly. You don't have to wait for them to find you through Google or an AI search tool again.

    If you want ready-made layouts for that follow-up, our free Figma email template pack is a good place to start.

    About the author

    Gavin Hewitson is the founder of In-box, a Klaviyo Master Gold Partner agency. Over five years, he and his team have worked with more than 500 brands on email and SMS. See their results at in-box.com/case-studies, or download their free Figma email template pack.

    Sources

      WhatsApp Karl